Showing posts with label film critics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label film critics. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

The Dangerous Lives of Movie Critics

So I, like Lauren, also read the article criticizing film critics, and at the risk of poaching her subject have a little to add, because this phenomenon of people discussing the worthlessness of critics was actually a factor in our decision to start a film blog. I think we might run into it more than most because of our frequent explorations in the venerable halls of the IMDb message boards, but the vitriol aimed at film critics is most of the time even more snobbish than a New Yorker review of a Michael Bay film. So often these people like to think of themselves as David tackling the Goliath of elitism, but in the end they just come across as playground bullies teasing the nerd because he wears glasses.

The fact is that most of the people that complain about film criticism don’t get that they’re not the audience for it anymore than Manohla Dargis of the New York Times is the audience for “X-Men 3: The Last Stand.” “X-Men 3,” like “Spiderman 3” and “Pirates of the Caribbean 3,” was going to make money no matter what the fraternity of movie critics said about it (people also seem to forget that actually the first incarnations of “X-men,” “Spiderman,” and “Pirates of the Caribbean” were generally liked by the critics). Quite frankly I find it hard to pity “Spiderman 3” for its poor reviews when it went to the bank with $336,530,303, and “The Lives of Others,” which I think is the best movie that has come out of this decade, made $11,284,657. When Joe Morgenstern of the Wall Street Journal gets attacked by hoards of crazy Batfans for giving a mixed review to “The Dark Knight,” which was almost universally praised and is the second highest grossing film of all time, one begins to think that these fanboys’ attentions are a little misguided. What do they want? The whole world to agree with them? It basically does, allow Joe Morgenstern to prefer “Tell No One,” “The Dark Knight” doesn’t need him, but a French thriller in limited release does. The same weekend that “The Dark Knight” made a record breaking $151,411,483 “Tell No One” made $400,947. Do you still feel like you’re David fighting the unjust Goliath of film snobbery?

I read articles on the internet tracking the weekend box office results and gleefully reporting that in spite of poor reviews a movie did spectacularly, or that the critics were wrong again. Well let me tell you the critics aren’t there to tell you whether or not a movie will be a success, they’re there to tell you if a movie is going to have anything to add to the medium of cinema. The remake of “Prom Night” might have opened at the top of the box office with more money than “The Lives of Others” made in its entire run, but who cares about that film now? It was a throw away piece of PG-13 horror that I doubt even the director cared about beyond using it as a stepping-stone from TV to movies. But if you can’t decide the quality of a movie democratically by how many people see it what are we left with? Is everyone’s opinion equal, or can we say that Anthony Lane of the New Yorker, who is educated in the history of film and has seen probably more movies than Quentin Tarantino (certainly he’s seen a broader range of movies than Tarantino), is a better judge of whether or not a movie should be added to the canon than Batdude666 who states that a movie sucked because it had character development instead of a knife wielding maniac in it? People who say that film criticism is obsolete in this age of blogs and podcasts don’t understand that reviews maybe dispensable for the likes of “Superman Returns,” but for a small movie like “The Lives of Others” or “Little Miss Sunshine” they can be the difference between a sleeper and a bomb. When was this golden age that people keep talking about where critics had the power to torpedo a blockbuster? It never happened; people will go to those movies anyway, be it 1948 or 2008, but movies that have little or no money for advertising need reviews or they will fail. “The Visitor” was a very fine movie, but I never would have given it a second glance to if it hadn’t been for a positive review from A.O. Scott.

I’m going to be lazy and finish with two quotes, which basically sum up everything I have to say. The first is probably familiar to you as it was intoned to perfection by Peter O’Toole in “Ratatouille,” and the second is by my favorite critic, Anthony Lane of the New Yorker.

“In many ways, the work of a critic is easy. We risk very little yet enjoy a position over those who offer up their work and their selves to our judgment. We thrive on negative criticism, which is fun to write and to read. But the bitter truth we critics must face, is that in the grand scheme of things, the average piece of junk is more meaningful than our criticism designating it so. But there are times when a critic truly risks something, and that is in the discovery and defense of the new. The world is often unkind to new talent, new creations. The new needs friends.”

“At a time when, for many viewers, the value of a motion picture is indicated by the rotation of a chubby thumb through 180 degrees, one should remind them that, of all the duties required of the professional critic, perhaps the least important – certainly the least enduring – is the delivery of a verdict. I am always sorry to hear that readers were personally offended, even scandalized, that my opinion of a film diverged from theirs. I wish I could convince them that I am merely starting an argument, as everyone does over dinner, or in a crowded bar, after going to see a film, and that their freedom to disagree is part of the fun.”

Saturday, September 20, 2008

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Embrace My Film Snobbery

I recently read an article about how terrible film critics are.  Out of touch with the general populace, snobbish, obsessed with those ancient films no one wants to see any more, lacking in an understanding of the great narrative intricacies of the superhero film seemed to be the basic consensus.  Whether the author was being serious is a question unto itself, as the article seemed to have been written in faux-teenage parlance and in the form of a top ten list.  But the complaints contained therein are incredibly common.  Whether this author was being serious or not, there are plenty of others who are.  

So, film critics? Do we need 'em? Do we even care? Cinema has long been considered a democratic mode of entertainment.  Everyone has an opinion on the latest new release.  Often it does not go past the 'dude, that was sweet!' point, but every once in awhile some enterprising young person with access to a computer, blackberry or iphone gets on the horn and starts telling everyone in the world just what he or she thought of 'Superman Returns'.  We all do it, we all think our opinion matters, we all want to be heard.  We're the ones the movie is aimed at, we buy the tickets, we love the stars.  So does that mean that our opinion is just as good as, or better than, the professional film critics? The people who don't buy tickets but get paid to give their opinion on Jessica Alba's riveting performance in 'The Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer'?

I happen to be one of those people, apparently in the minority, who do enjoy those ancient films no one cares about.  Forgive me if I cannot see the poetry in Michael Bay's 'Transformers', for I would much rather watch Lang's 'Metropolis'.  Yes, I do refer to 'The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari' as simply 'Caligari' because, well, everyone who matters has seen it.  I am more interested in Antonioni's projections of lost identity and alienation than I am in watching Dane Cook wrestle with Kate Hudson.  Strange, to be sure, but true.  That is not to say that I don't enjoy the everyday.  I laughed all the way through 'Tropic Thunder' and 'Anchorman', and 'The Dark Knight' kept me anchored to my seat for its entire running time.  To like films like 'The 400 Blows' does not mean that one cannot like 'Hellboy'.  Del Toro is as worthy of interest as Truffaut.

I can accept the criticism that professional film critics need to lighten up, that they at times can seem snobby, self-satisfied and, because a film is not non-linear and French, find no value in it.  And there are critics who have made a career out of being curmudgeons.  Lest we forget that the greatest films of yesteryear were, in fact, also the popular films.  'Casablanca' was meant to be a B-melodrama, after all.  We should not, however, overvalue some of the tripe audiences are fed today because they might be classics tomorrow.  I do not foresee a great demand in the future for reissuing 'Pearl Harbor', even as a historical curiosity.  And I will never, though I enjoyed every minute of it, accept the idea that 'The Dark Knight' is of greater cinematic value than 'The Thousand Eyes of Dr. Mabuse'.

And let us also face facts.  Beyond the mere opinions of the professional film critics, they are better writers! Sit and read Anthony Lane's remarkably grumpy reviews in 'The New Yorker'.  Even if you disagree with him (and pray to God that you do!), he writes well.  He's funny.  He's amusing.  And he's intelligent.  

Film is a democratic medium, but that does not mean that the lowest common denominator is always right.  People may flock to see Adam Sandler and ignore Charlie Chaplin but, for those of us who have actually watched a Chaplin film and not just complained about the lack of sound, Chaplin will remain the superior comedian.  Not because Chaplin is in black and white, not because there is no sound, not because so many of his films were made before 1930, but because (brace yourself!) he's funnier! 

Having an education in film does not mean going to film school and being taught about soviet montage.  It means seeing all kinds of film, enjoying all kinds of film, appreciating what is good and laughing at what is bad.  If the professional critics are too obsessed with the obscure and the old, the critics of the critics are too obsessed with how Spiderman is portrayed.  Popular does not equal bad, but save us if it automatically equals good.       

There has been too much 'us versus them' on both sides of the equation.  I sit in my cinema studies classes and talk with people who adore 'Freddy Vs. Jason' AND 'Last Year at Marienbad', all at the same time.  Amazing.  We are the snobs of tomorrow, and the ones who merrily embrace Ben Stiller.  And to those noisy opinionated members of the Imdb message boards who have never seen a black and white film, stop acting like you are in the majority.  For the snobs and the cineastes are part of the public too and know what they like.  If we must forget Chaplin and only have Sandler, if we must reject 'Rear Window' in favor of 'Disturbia', then we have lost the argument that made film into an intellectual medium, something actually worthy of study, something worthy to be venerated.  And with that we have lost some honest expressions of our culture, of our history.  More than that, we have lost some damn fine entertainment.